Sex With Boys OK For Teachers
TEACHERS will for the first time be allowed to
have legal homosexual sex with students
aged just 17 under a little-known section of the gay sex
reform Bill passed by State
Parliament's lower house last night.
The Carr Government's social revolution began to unravel yesterday,
as it came under
strong attack for its controversial underage sex Bill
and proposed pain-relieving cannabis
trial.
Premier Bob Carr appeared undecided as to how cannabis will be
administered to sick
people and refused to rule out government-sanctioned pot plantations.
Meanwhile, it's been revealed that the legal age of homosexual sex
between teachers and
male students will be lowered from 18 to 17 under the gay sex Bill.
As well, Attorney-General Bob Debus last night was forced to make
embarrassing last-minute amendments to his Bill.
Amid a day of furious debate in State Parliament, 'National Party
State MP for Orange
Russell Turner said he would support the Bill after revealing that
his son, Scott, was gay.
The Daily Telegraph has discovered Mr Debus' "age of consent" Bill lowers
the age at
which male teachers can have sex wjth their
students, and not face criminal prosecution.
At present, a teacher can have sex with a female student aged 17
and male student aged
18 and not face criminal prosecution.
However, the Bill reduces the age for male students to 17, to bring this
law into line with
the current rule for female students.
Mr Debus last night said he would remove another contentious
section of the Bill, which
retrospectively makes many people who had committed illegal
gay sex acts in the past
immune from prosecution.
This retrospective clause meant that any person who was facing an
allegation or was
under suspicion of illegal under-age sex in the past, where the partner
was aged 16-18
and the act was consensual, could not have been prosecuted.
ALP State KP Paul Gibson earlier said this clause was a disgrace.
"This Bill is for the
protection of paedophiles out there now," he said. "This Bill is
saying if you're a
paedophile you've won the lottery.
"I've seen a lot of legislation in the 16 years I've been here, but I
haven't seen more vile
legislation than the retrospective part of this Bill - I'm sure it's a
total sham."
Another section of the Bill will also be scrapped, which would
have unintentionally allowed
men to legally have sex with child male prostitutes aged 14-18,
as long as they looked
over 18.
At 7.30pm, State Parliament's Legislative Assembly approved
the Bill 54-32, with it to go
before the Legislative Council in coming days.
Government MPs to vote against the Bill included Joe Tripodi, Richard
Amery, Tony
Stewart and Kevin Greene, while Opposition Leader John Brogden
and Coalition MPs
Judy-Hopwood, Jillian Skinner, Brad Hazzard and Andrew
Humpherson voted in favour.
Mr Turner spoke in favour of the Bill. "I have spoken to my son on many
occasions and the
National Party understands my situation where my
son is a homosexual.
"I would hope in supporting this bill, and I will be voting for this bill,
that slowly some of the
ignorance and some of the fear that we have in
our community will dissipate."
Scott Turner is aged 39 but realised in his
early 20s he was gay.
Mr Turner said the proposed law would have been unlikely to have
affected his son, who
was probably "still trying to determine
his identity" between the ages of 16-18.
He said his experience as a parent of a gay man allowed him to have
a "better
understanding" on the bill.
A MESS OF HIS OWN MAKING
Comment by David Penberthy
HAVING been less than candid with voters about two contentious
social policies, Bob Carr
yesterday seemed less than prepared.
On the age of consent and the cannabis reforms, the Premier has
become tangled in the
details of both proposals.
The implications of the retrospectivity clause in the consent Bill, and the
confusion over
the home cultivation of marijuana, are important questions hanging
over these reforms.
They are likely to be the subject of flip-flopping by Mr Carr.
His former minister, Richard Amery, said in opposing the consent Bill
yesterday that
neither party had mentioned the proposal during the election campaign.
A fair point. With an open debate ahead of the election, Mr Carr
could have not only kept
the voters in the picture, but sorted out the details of these proposals.
HOW YOUR LOCAL MP VOTED LAST NIGHT
THIS is how NSW Legislative Assembly MPs voted last night on the
Bill to lower the age
of consent for homosexual males to 16 years of age:
IN FAVOUR
Pam Allan, Alan Ashton, Diane Beamer, Matthew Brown, Linda Bumey,
Cherie Burton,
David Campbell, Bob Carr, Barry Collier, Geoff Corrigan, Paul Crittenden,
Angela
D'Amore, Bob Debus, Tanya Gadiel, Bryce Gaudry, Kerry Hickey,
Jeff Hunter, Morris
lemma, Virginia Judge, Kristina Keneally, Craig Knowles, Paul Lynch,
Gerard Martin, Paul
McLeay, Reba Meagher, Alison Megarrity, John Mills, Matthew Moms,
Neville Newell,
Sandra Nori, Milton Orkopoulos, Karyn Paluzzano, Paul Pearce, Barbara
Perry, John
Price, Andrew Refshauge, Frank Sartor, Carl Scully, John Watkins,
Graham West, Steve
Whan, Kirn Yeadon, Gladys Berejiklian, John Brogden, Shelley Hancock,
Brad Hazzard,
Judy Hopwood, Andrew Humpherson, Peta Seaton, Jillian Skinner,
Russell Turner, David
Ban", Clover Moore, Rob Oakeshott.
AGAINST
Richard Amery, Marie Andrews, Paul Gibson, Kevin Greene,
Noreen Hay, Grant McBride,
Marianne Saliba, Tony Stewart, Joe Tripodi, Greg Aplin, Andrew
Constance, Peter
Debnam, Chris Hartcher, Malcolm Kerr, Daryl Maguire, Wayne
Merton, Barry O'Farrell,
Steven Pringle, Michael Richardson, Anthony Roberts, Andrew
Tink, Stephen Cansdell,
Andrew Fraser, Thomas George, Donald Page, Adrian Piccoli,
lan Slack-Smith, George
Souris, Andrew Stoner, Peter Draper, Tony McGrane, Richard Torbay.
ABSENT
lan Armstrong, Peter Black, Katrina Hodgkinson, John Turner.
ABSTAIN
John Bartlett
Mirror Australian Telegraph Publications
Mark Skelsey-(22-5-2003)
|
|