Vanstone Defends Detaining Children
IMMIGRATION Minister Amanda Vanstone
has defended leaving some children
locked up in detention despite the
surprise release of a three-year-old girl and a newborn boy.
The Government on Monday agreed
to release Naomi Leong, 3, and her
mother Virginia from Villawood
detention centre in Sydney.
It also agreed yesterday to allow newborn
Michael Andrew Tran and his Vietnamese
asylum-seeker parents to stay in community
detention in Perth rather than return to Christmas Island.
ABC radio today reported another
three-year-old girl remained locked
up at Port Augusta and a two-year-old was still being held on Nauru.
Asked why the Government had released
some children from detention and not others, Senator
Vanstone said each case was considered individually.
Ideally, no children would be held in detention, but
at the same time they could not be separated from
their parents who were locked up, she said.
"And we don't want to say to people smugglers, `If
you pick customers who have children you will be
able to guarantee that they can get to Australia
and walk around freely'," Senator Vanstone told ABC radio.
"So this is a sort of a rock and a hard place if
you like.
"But the circumstances of each family, the legal
action they're involved in, the entitlements of the
child might vary according to their immigration
circumstances, so there isn't a simple blanket rule."
Senator Vanstone also criticised Liberal backbenchers
behind private member's Bills calling for the release
of asylum seekers from long-term detention.
The Bills, to be introduced by Liberal MP Petro Georgiou,
have received backing from party colleagues including
Judi Moylan, Bruce Baird, Russell Broadbent and Marise Payne.
Senator Vanstone said she had not seen the Bills but
expected they would be filled with problems.
"I would have hoped that members would recognise that
the policies we've put in place have been effective, that
is just obvious – the boats aren't coming like they were in 1999, 2000, 2001," she said.
"I'd hope they'd look at that and say, 'Well look, this
is a government that's moving with the times, that's
acknowledging change and moving ahead', and they'd stick with us.
"But if they want to make their point, that's what the
Liberal Party's about, we don't kick people out because they have a different view."
AAP (26-5-2005)
|
|