Why Do So Many Sex Cases 'Drop Out' Of System
SOUTH AUSTRALIAN
Chief Justice John Doyle
has called for an urgent
inquiry on why so many
reported sexual offences
"drop out" of the system.
Giving evidence at Parliament's legislative review
committee yesterday. Chief
Justice Doyle said an investigation into the large disparity in reported offences
and those that end up in
court should be conducted
as soon as possible.
"I think a really close inquiry at the very earliest
stage would be well worth
doing," he said "None of us
really knows why so many
are dropping out."
The committee has been
investigating sexual assault
since 2003 after calls from
women's groups and sexual
assault victims for a review
of sex-attack laws.
An issues paper for the
committee includes sexual
assault data for 2002, which
shows that of the 628 rapes
recorded by police in SA.
108 were referred to the
Magistrates Court and 47
were committed to higher
courts. Only 19 guilty convictions were recorded.
Of the 725 indecent assaults recorded by police,
113 were referred to the
Magistrates Court, 13 were
committed to higher courts
and 10 guilty verdicts were
recorded. With unlawful
sexual intercourse cases,
254 were recorded by police,
64 were referred to the
magistrates court, 44 were
committed to higher courts.
There were 31 convictions.
After yesterday's committee bearing, committee
member Liberal MP Angus
Bedford said he endorsed
Chief Justice Doyle's inquiry call.
"If victims can hang in
there till it gets to court, the
conviction rates will be
much higher," he said.
"We've got to look at how
we can give victims a
greater level of confidence
in the system. We've got to
confront that head on."
Victim Support Service
chief executive Michael
Dawson said: "If an inquiry
is a way to bring it to a head
and to get something done.
I'm very supportive.
"We know that there's a
lot of victim blaming by the
community. When they go
to court, (victims) are required to talk about their
sexual behaviour, their
lifestyle behaviour and that
leads people to make totally
unwarranted judgments
about victims.
"That very much leads to
victim blaming."
AAP (2-6-2005)
Jemma Chapman
|
The figures
Rape-2002
Reported by police: 628
Referred to Magistrates Court:108
Referred to a higher court: 47
Guilty convictions: 19
Indecent assaults-2002
Reported by police: 725
Referred to Magistrates Court:113
Referred to a higher court:13
Guilty convictions: 10
|
|